| March 6, 2006
The Honorable John C. Dugan
Comptroller
Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
Department of the Treasury
250 E Street, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20219
Dear Comptroller Dugan:
America””s Community Bankers is writing to you to express our concern with an
ordinance recently adopted in Montgomery County, Maryland and its affect on
financial institutions and residential mortgage lending in that county. The
Montgomery County Council (“Council”) adopted Ordinance 36-04, entitled
“Commission on Human Rights Discrimination in Housing” (“Ordinance”), which is
scheduled to take effect, tomorrow, March 7, 2006. We believe that the Ordinance
will adversely affect residential mortgage lending in Montgomery County and
respectfully request that your office formally review the Ordinance for
consistency with federal law.
ACB is committed to ensuring that all Americans have fair and equitable access
to credit and that consumers have the necessary skills to make wise credit and
other financial decisions. ACB supports the development of national,
anti-predatory lending standards to create uniformity and ensure consistency
among locality-based mortgage lending initiatives.
Although the Ordinance has been codified under the Consumer Protection, and
Human Rights and Civil Liberties chapters of the Montgomery County Code, the
legislative history clearly shows that the purpose of the Ordinance is to
regulate lending practices in Montgomery County in an effort to curb predatory
lending. The Maryland State legislature adopted several anti-predatory lending
measures in 2002.
Lenders and investors have raised concern that the Ordinance will not achieve
its goal because the language is vague and ill-defined, yet imposes severe
penalties for any violation. The concern is that a lender or investor will be
subject to liability without being able to determine what loans would be
considered “discriminatory” under the Ordinance.
The American Financial Services Association and seven mortgage lenders have
filed suit to invalidate the Ordinance. National City Mortgage Co., Bear
Stearns, and Lehman Brothers”” Aurora Loan Services LLC among others have decided
not to lend in Montgomery County citing concerns about vague requirements,
excessive penalties, and potentially unlimited liability. Thus, the effect of
the Ordinance would appear to be to curtail legitimately supplied credit to the
borrowers about which the Council is most concerned.
Based on the above, ACB urges your office to review the Ordinance””s effect on
national banks and to take appropriate action. We have made a similar request to
the Office of Thrift Supervision with respect to federally chartered savings
associations. We appreciate your prompt attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Diane Casey-Landry
|